Hours
Wed-Sun, noon-8pm; Mon-Tue, closed
Nearby Subway Stops
D, F, N, Q at Coney Island-Stillwell Ave.
Prices
$15.50-$18
Payment Methods
Cash Only
Special Features
- Good for Groups
- Kid-Friendly
- Lunch
Alcohol
Reservations
Not Accepted
Profile
A medieval crust, a sloppy splash of sauce, and the sweetest, freshest mozzarella make the pie at this famous pizza shack the best of its coal-oven kind by a wide margin. The occasional pizzaiolo outburst, the casual policy concerning store hours (open until the dough runs out), and the no-frills, airplane-wine-bottle selection only add to the charm. Forget about the Manhattan branches and their foggy affiliations. Every self-respecting pizza-loving New Yorker should visit the Coney Island original at least once in his lifetime. Go soon before they run out of dough permanently. - Rob Patronite and Robin Raisfeld
Note Totonno's only serves pizza by the pie.